For Season 10 news visit:
CharmedComicFan has moved
Charmed Comic Fan has moved. This site will remain as it is. I will not close it so you can always have access to the content here.
Thank you so much for following it for 2+ years!
But it is time to move to a new site for all news season 10!
From now and on all news will be in CHARMEDCOMICFAN10
Bookmark it!
Paul's thank you message to the fans
"Thanks to all the Charmed fans for coming along with us on the journey through season 9. Hope you enjoyed it!!"
-
#1
Paul has revived Charmed fully, for example Prue, which I'm eternally grateful for, but overall, Season 9 has been epic and promising for another great Season! If only he had been found sooner then the show would have ended on a better note. But, I guess better late than never will suffice. Anyway, thanks to Paul for being awesomely charming! :D Pumped for issue 25!
-
#2
I agree, if this had been the final season, fans would of loved it. Its a shame because I love the character of Prue, and yes a recast may not have been ideal, but better than nothing.
-
#3
I honestly do not understand the cover for #25 after the ending to #24... Can't wait to see how they spin it :D
-
#4
Hey guys, I've had a problem with my comic ordering, so never got the Darklight Zone, hence the lack of reviews. However I am happy to report that a Power of 300 review WILL be on my channel very soon :)
More Charmed #24 previews
The big battle begins!
With these 2 new previews we have a total of 6 pages.
For those who want to be spoiled and spoil the Spoilers section is open HERE
-
#1
Could anyone who read the issue write a synopsis in the spoiler section?
-
#2
in the second picture what kind power used in the second image before phoebe use her power??????????
-
#3
An advanced form of Telekinetic Orbing. Paige scattered the soldier's orbs around the world.
-
#4
oH MY GOD PERFECT POWER!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IT IS SOMETHING LIKE COMBUSTION POWER !!!!!!
-
#5
i really love rubine's work !! she/he is better than Dean kortz
-
#6
because comparinf issue 12(dean kortz work) and issue 24 not the storyline only the work issue 24 it is really better
-
#7
Rubine has done a good job, but i don't recognize the Charmed universe anymore ... but well i guess the Charmedverse has evolved.
Their powers are unrecognizable (i mean the art...)especially in this issue. And there is a big lack of backgrounds in Rubine's work...
I preferred Dean Kotz's art, but Rubine does the job pretty well.
Great issue, but too much enhanced magic going on over there... i wonder what paul will come up with in the next finale
Charmed #24 previews
Here they are!
Art by Rubine, Colors by John Hunt
And my favorite quote
EAT PLANTS!
-
#1
I wasnt so sure about rubine but I am defo a fan of him/her now , and coloring is great so far
-
#2
and in these previews coop, elise and piper have amazing likenesses
-
#3
I didn't know Obama was in this issue! lol
-
#4
great! but i'm still not a fan of the art, i think Kotz is a better artist :)
-
#5
Well, I think Rubine has drawn the sisters very well, and Kotz has drawn a lot of issues... It's time for Rubine's artwork! But I really think that the best artwork was in issue 19 with Fowler!
-
#6
Was Max in there?
-
#7
@Julie - I wondered that, too. I'm leaning toward no since Max is a witch and as far as we know only the Charmed Ones got their powers back of the magical world. I'm not going to say a definite no, mostly because I want it to be him.
-
#8
No, that one is Henry!!! I know... he's awful!!
-
#9
And the blonde woman is Bailey! And not Miss Donovan
-
#10
Why does Henry look like a black guy?
-
#11
@Henry - Pretty much on par with Dave Hoover's Henry (only family member of his that I really couldn't stand). Of course the color is on John Hunt, but he probably didn't realize that it was Henry or he'd have done that differently. He has colored Henry before after all.
Weird about Bailey's hair color change. -
#12
@StoryGirls83 The last Henry's picture is good!! He's like Henry in that one... But one panel in a full issue is not enough! I like John Hunt's work, but it's been a real problem recognize Bailey with that hair!
-
#13
@Henry - Since I have read the whole issue, I do know what you mean. I was specifically referencing that picture on the first page. And believe me, I like John Hunt's work, too, so so much better than Dash Martin's. I hope this time they keep him longer, because I would enjoy having him back for longer.
On an off note. I was thrilled to finally have Bailey's occupation confirmed (I wasn't sure if she was a librarian or a teacher who liked research). Now if only she would get a last name. Recurring characters deserving last names (and no I don't just mean her).
Previews update
Zenescope wrote on FB:
- Available day and date digital through Comixology tomorrow, Charmed #24 and Robyn Hood #1 !!!
- The new releases you'll find on store shelves are: Charmed #24. GFT Bad Girls #3. GFT presents The Jungle Book TPB!
Also about the previews of #24 Zenescope replied:
- we won't have the ability to do that (show previews) until after the book is released.
-
#1
yeah! now we're sure that issue 24 comes out tomorrow :)) i'm so scared for Prue... i hope so much she'll be well and that she'll stay.
-
#2
that's fine by me, I would have avoided previews with it being the finale anyway... until realizing I have no will power when it comes to spoilers. So best they're not releasing them yet :p
-
#3
comixology will probably have some previews tomorrow
10/3
-
#1
5 days guys!
-
#2
Eeek :D Any idea when a volume 4 cover might be released?
-
#3
the cover for a volume (the finished one with logos) usually gets released some days before the volumes release. So i guess we will have it in the first days of October
-
#4
any previews???
-
#5
Monday or Tuesday
-
#6
It says on amazon volume 4 out on 8th january
-
#7
I pre-ordered mine awhile ago and my copy is coming on october so I think that is a second batch coming out on january
-
#8
Based on my own pre-ordering experiences, Amazon aren't very reliable when it comes to release dates... I think a lot of the time they just pick a really late one to cover themselves. I'd just trust Zenescope
-
#9
yes, amazon is always not accurate about the dates. Zenescope said volume 4 is still coming october 9
-
#10
@charmedcomicfan - Do you mean 10th? The 9th is a Tuesday.
-
#11
hi Kostas, do you know if Zenescope's planning to release some previews before tomorrow? it's the better way to be sure that the issue will be out
-
#12
i contacted a site that released previews and they replied:
"Zenescope hasn't provided them yet. It might not be until next week as the guy that does them is apparently out sick."
That was last week, but previews are still not out, so maybe we won't get previews at all this time.
Comixology will probably release some tomorrow
Next Week : Charmed #24
1 week left for the Season 9 finale and Zenescope confirms it on facebook
- Next week's releases are:
- Bad Girls #3 , Charmed #24 (the season finale!), The Jungle Book trade paperback, and, of course, ROBYN HOOD #1!
-
#1
Sweet! The Charmed season nine finale, more Nathan, and family getting to meet Robyn. (not to mention some Smallville and Wonderland and Godstorm. Two of which come out this week, but I don't have time to get). Awesome week for comics next week.
-
#2
I wish it came today :(
-
#3
Previews would be nice haha
-
#4
they sure would be. We will have them soon
Charmed #24 officially coming 10/3
Charmed #24 will be released October 3rd.
The news are coming from Zenescope.
-
#1
I guess its better this way, I'd rather have them take their time and make a good, quality, amazing season nine finale that we'll remember then a rushed piece that doesn't reach It's full potential...
-
#2
I hope it's worth waiting for...
-
#3
im just wondering how theyre going to wrap everything up in one issue, unless season ten is going to be a direct continuation
-
#4
I wonder too Paul. What do you guys think would have happened in the comics had Alyssa left the show and not Shannen? Do you think Alyssa would have let her image be used in the show and comics?
-
#5
I think it depends on how severe the problem is...If Alyssa has resentment toward the show, I'm sure she won't let the producers to use her image...so phoebe would have looked different too..lol
-
#6
Well at the same time, we're still unsure as to whether Shannen ever directly declined letting her likeness be used, as that one Twitter convo proved, she wasnt aware of it until that point...
-
#7
Due to the difference in Shannen and Alyssa's contracts (at least from what I've heard) they might well have been able to use Alyssa's image on the show so long as they paid her for it whether she wanted them to or not and likewise, she might not have had as much sway in her image being used for Phoebe in the comics as Shannen does for her image being used for Prue. I guess unless we get a very candid interview with those involved we probably will never know for sure. And that interview is unlikely to happen.
-
#8
I saw somewhere that shannens owns 5% of charmed thats probably the reason she may have more sway in her image being used
-
#9
I can believe that. People give Shannen a hard time, but having her as the lead witch (not to mention in another Spelling show) was a HUGE part of why the WB picked it up in the first place. We may not have had Charmed if it wasn't for her.
-
#10
Thank you everyone. And I agree with P3nathan. We likely wouldn't have had Charmed if it wasn't for her. Which is probably why she owns 5% of Charmed. Also, please check out my Charmed Alternate Season 4 Fanfiction where Prue lives and Phoebe dies. http://charmedthevirtualseries.wikia.com/wiki/Charmed:_The_Virtual_Series_Wiki
It is very different from the start of my season 4. The fanfiction actually includes a variation of Paige's whitelighter side and hint...Victor is Paige's father. -
#11
Sorry you guys.
http://charmedthevirtualseries.wikia.com/wiki/Charmed:_The_Virtual_Series_Wiki
Vote! Favorite Season 9 Drawn Cover!
-
#1
#24 got my vote, but 17 and 22 were also good.
-
#2
20. That cover was just Piper fan heaven
-
#3
17 was my favorite.
-
#4
Same 17, it was between 17, 20, 22, 24
-
#5
8, the most inspiring. Voted 4 though because I used the eightth button.
-
#6
did you realised that each flashback in issue 23 is set during a specific decade, the 50s (nancy), 60s, 70s, 80s and the 90s ? :)
-
#7
Any news for charmed #24?
-
#8
Not yet sorry. It is supposed to be released next week but Paul said he isnt very sure about the date we have and it may be released one week later (October 3rd). Also previewsworld released the list for 9/26 comics and charmed is not in it. So, we'll see
-
#9
My guess it will be 10/3.
-
#10
as it is the last issue of the season, do you reckon we'll see the door being closed in the time honoured tradition? perhaps prue could close it, like she did in season one and two, with her powers, or maybe one of the kids or something?
-
#11
I really believe paul will not stop the tradition of closing the Manor's door at the end of a season
-
#12
I hope season 9 finale will be like season 3 finale, but with Charmed Ones (and Prue) alive... But the story needs some victims frome the side of good!
-
#13
@charmed comic fan in your tweet in which you put the twitters from fans, my twitter you've got it wrong, my twitter is @jesusdiazcrespo , no uppercase, lowercase only
-
#14
I'm definitely expecting at least one death, considering how big the fight is supposedly going to be. I can't think of a character that I wouldn't be sad to see go though, mortal or magical. Although I guess death doesn't mean never seeing them again, but it would still be very sad.
-
#15
I think it is wrong, maybe I'm wrong, you could look at it and if I could change this bad? my real twitter is @jesusdiazcrespo :)
-
#16
Zoe I don't think that they will kill Coop at the end of season 9 because he is the less interesting character around there. Probably they will kill a character that people adore. The less interesting ones always remain. Probably Prue or Cole because they are technically dead.
-
#17
@Steph - Not to mention the fact that they seemed to be trying to follow the finale and Coop still has another child to father.
-
#18
Why would they do that? Why would they kill a character that most people love instead of killing one that most people consider it boring. Paul said at SDCC in 2010 I saw it on you tube, that they are going to try to follow the finale and the show itself, but if they don't agree with something they will try to contradict it in a logical way. So you never know what is going to happen.
-
#19
Never say never!
-
#20
Why do they have to kill someone from the good camp, I don't want that and I wouldn't like that. If they want to kill some of the good guys I think Steph has a point Zoe they are not going to kill Coop. I don't think that they are going to kill Prue or Cole because it would be very predictable and most people I think that they would expect this. I don't know how is that possible to kill them if they are already dead. So it would remain Leo which I don't think they have the brave to do that because fans will be angry, Henry I don't think so because Paul seems to love Henry, at least this is my impression, so it remains Daryl which I am almost sure that Paul would kill him. Why him and not Coop? Well because they probably want to have a huge reaction from people. At least this is what I saw that most people which write coomics do. I also read other 2 comics besides this one and in the finale of one of them one of the characters that people loved was killed by other character that people really loved. They could have picked a character that nobody cared about, but no they wanted reactions from fans and they were not positive ones. I think that they are still having reactions from the fans because of that. I maybe wrong, I hope I am wrong because I don't want anybody from the good camp to die.
-
#21
Well Ana if this happens I will be very upset. I hope that you won't be right.
-
#22
I love Daryl but his death would be cool. The sisters would be upset and we know that when this happens they do great things (Piper as fury was great)!
-
#23
I say that it would be much more interesting if Coop dies, I don't want Daryl to die.
-
#24
I hope so too Zoe I will be very upset if Daryl dies because I love Daryl. As for Coop I am very indifferent if he lives or if he dies. But again I don't think that they will kill Coop, we won't get rid of him so easly. And if Paul wants to kill someone I would warmly advise him to kill demons from the evil camp and leave the good guys alone.
-
#25
I actually hope Coop dies. That way we can have Phoebe and Cole back together. Cole could help Phoebe grieve and they fall back in love. But, what about the season 8 finale? Are they ever gonna identify this as what will really happen or one of Phoebe's premonitions?
-
#26
I like the way you think Barron .
-
#27
I don't think results from season 8 was a premonition.
-
#28
That would be very nice Barron, but I don't understand someting, I didn't understand the premonition part. And it would be impossible the events from season 8 to be the result of a premonition. Why would they have written season 9 the way they did if it was just a premonition?
-
#29
I betcha Barron thinks this is Dallas Ana. If you never saw the old Dallas reruns.
Charmed #24 coming 1 week later?
Paul Ruditis:
- I hate to be a killjoy, but you MIGHT have to wait one more week. I'm not entirely sure about that release date.
Paul is not very sure about the release date and Zenescope hasnt updated on a new date so nothing is sure yet. We'll have to wait and see.
-
#1
But what does that mean exactly? One more week past when they said it would be? Or one more week past this next Wednesday (which would be when they said it would be).
-
#2
I'd say a week after the release date cus he says I'm not sure about THAT release date
-
#3
1 week after the date we already have (september 26)
-
#4
oh please..don't let it be another delay :(
Charmed #25 HQ cover
David Seidman shared an HQ version of his Charmed #25 cover
I uploaded it in CharmedComicFan10
-
#1
Great to see a HQ version (although without the logo), that's definitely the Manor now that we have a clearer look. I love the cover overall...but is it just me or does Piper's face look a bit off?
-
#2
what i get from Piper's face is anger
-
#3
Definitely. "Piper the Surly Ghost" is my suggestion for the title :P (Presuming they are meant to be ghosts).
-
#4
The absolutely look like ghosts , gooood I really want to know how season 9 is going to end.
-
#5
no cliffhanger please!!!
-
#6
I believe there is going to be a cliffhanger or something to be honest
-
#7
if they are ghosts, the odds have changed now prues not sorta and they are.
-
#8
I guess we'll find out later this month.
-
#9
Wyatt turns ten: birthday project for the Simmons twins http://www.simmons-boys.com/.
-
#10
OMG they grew up! Don't think they're going to look anything like Wez Ramsey lol.
-
#11
I think Prue will become a bigger focus in season 10 while Piper, Phoebe, and Paige are stuck in the ghostly plane. Prue must find a way to save her sisters while they have their own run-ins with demons and ghosts from the past.
-
#12
@Barron - That would be cool if we got to see some of the innocents they didn't save, again. And I'm all for more Prue. I'm not going to take all of that from the cover, but if you actually are along the rig track I'm certain I would enjoy it.
Coming Soon! Charmed #24 ad
The ad says "Coming Next Month" but we all know the issue is going to be released in 19 days, September 26.
-
#1
yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
#2
where was that picture of kit taken from in the familiars section under species?
-
#3
Charmed #19, when Paige puts make up to the fictional detective, Richard Quinn
-
#4
something i dont understand people are always ragging on dean kotz... but when he did issue 9 and 12 people didnt seem to have a problem...
-
#5
prue should move back into the manor next season if theres a spare room/it still exists after the finale
-
#6
Personally i dont think Prue will become regular. I dont think we will ever have conversations like "Good Morning Prue, coffee is ready etc"
But i really hope she drops by in the story from time to time in S10 or that she gets a beautiful ending in #24 or a oneshot. I really believe Prue deserves a oneshot -
#7
the thing is, now that shes back i really want her integrated into the sisters lives, especially paiges life- I want ALL FOUR SISTERS to share the bond that paige and prue share with piper and phoebe. Also Charmed followers the story of the halliwell sisters and prue IS one of the halliwell sisters so now that she is back, she should very well be made into a main character again!
-
#8
however, there is the argument that charmed follows THE CHARMED ONES and prue is no longer a charmed one which i understand, i still hope then that she would at least be made as important as say someone like leo. She really couldnt work around the people she used to at 415 because they would recognize her soul but maybe she could work at magic school
-
#9
prue not a regular seriously the husbands are regulars so prue should be aswell and get story.
-
#10
I´m one of those who think that it would be natural for Prue to be a regular character , but just for a logical reason.
Piper and Paige grew up with Prue , she died and it was devastating for the characters , would it really make sense that after she´s back they only see her every once in a while as if she was an stranger. Nop -
#11
The reason I personally don't think she'll be a regular is because she's still technically dead. She's a spirit who's taken over a body... an empty body granted, but I still don't think she can stay that way forever.
-
#12
@p3nathan she would stay alive for the sheer reason it solves the shannen issue- if she dies again shes going to go back to being a spirit which would mean they would have to make an excuse as to why we never see her (since they cant show shannens likeness) so for that reason alone they have to keep her alive!
-
#13
I'm not sure if that outweighs the entire order and rules set by life and death...
-
#14
I would love Prue to fight with the angel of death just like she did in season 3 !
-
#15
@p3nathan but since patience actual soul was stolen but yet her body was still alive it was kind like a swop done in styx feet under.... prue resumed the life of a living person and patience took the spot of someone dead
-
#16
swap*** done in styx feet under
-
#17
Maybe season 10 will include the kidnap of Prue's soul (possibly by Charon?) if she sticks around. A spirit of a Charmed One who is no longer alive and is not permanently attached to a body is bound to be highly wanted by evil. This way, Prue is not physically there, but is still involved in the storyline.
-
#18
@p4fan4ever- But in that case Death would be losing two souls. One to Charon and one taking over the body of the former. Not sure that'd work. But we'll see
Charmed #24 completed/fixed cover
The cover on the left is the completed/fixed one
The changes are: Toned down colors, Piper's jaw and Paige's hair
The cover on the right is the one we had so far to see the differences
-
#1
I like the new!!!! and now the weapon of paige is blue not green!!!!
-
#2
if you see clear at the cover you will see that prue has a bow!!
at issue 23 she has a crossbow!!!!!!!! -
#3
Paige doesnt have a weapon, it is one of her orbs based powers
-
#4
I hope we get to see prue and phoebe fight like they did in the show
-
#5
@charmedcomicfan Right! was wrong
-
#6
has already gone on sale in print charmed the number 23? I just came esk travel, and for informing and if so go to my comic book store
-
#7
I really don´t know why they don´t feature Prue in covers more often , it just seems natural
-
#8
I think Phoebe's power surge inside the dome may explain the different ways Piper and Paige's powers appear here.
-
#9
Concerning the power surge, wouldnt it be amazing if Phoebe was levitating next to Leo in the #24 cover? instead of just having part of her face shown?
-
#10
I had an image of my head of what I imagined the 1st s10 cover would look like. The sisters looking outward onto what is presumably a bunch of demons, Piper melting the street before them, Paige orbing the BOS into her hands and Phoebe flying above them.
-
#11
*had an image IN my head lol
Charmed #25 - Coming Soon ad
This ad is from Wonderland 2.
It says:
- The Girls are back with more Awesome Spellcasting Action!
- Charmed #25 Coming Soon
And of course there is a preview of the cover for Charmed #25
Thanks to Storygirl83 for sharing
Note: All Charmed Season 10 news will be archived and categorized in CharmedComicFan10 (and not in CharmedComicFan). Visit http://charmedcomicfan10.jimdo.com/
Charmed #25 cover
Our first look from Season 10! The cover for Charmed #25!!
The quality is not the best because it was just a small ad in the Wonderland comic.
Big thanks to StoryGirl83 for finding it and sharing!
Note: All Charmed Season 10 news will be archived and categorized in CharmedComicFan10 (and not in CharmedComicFan). So, visit http://charmedcomicfan10.jimdo.com/
CharmedComicFan10 will become the main site when Season 10 starts in Early 2013
-
#1
Aaaaaah!!! So awesome. They look like goddesses
-
#2
I've been looking at that image over and over since I first saw it and does anyone else thing that's the manor with a lot of missing pieces behind them? And do they look a bit ghostly?
I know the cover doesn't always tell you a lot, but what do you think? -
#3
Those are definitely the steps leading up to the Manor..and you're right, they have ghost legs. Oh the theories in my head right now :P
-
#4
surely the manor. I wonder if this cover reflects the aftermath of the season 9 finale battle
-
#5
Maybe the sisters are going to transcend. Any Angel fans, think Cordy at the end of s3. Perhaps this is what the full potential of the power of 3 will get them! Like I said, the theories in my head right now lol
-
#6
Oh i see what you mean! Maybe they will be given the chance to become something higher, higher beings. Now that would be interesting! But of course there is a big chance this is just artistic and means nothing. Cannot wait
-
#7
Haha yes... this could easily be an issue 1 cover "Oh my God, Piper can control plants now?" moment :P
-
#8
I also like that this cover kinda reflects Charmed #1 cover. Piper in the middle Phoebe on the right and Paige on the left. Also Piper has her hands open like the #1 cover. Lastly notice that this cover is mostly light blue like the season 5 DVD. Perhaps it will also be used for the volume
-
#9
LOVE IT!
-
#10
i think this MAY just be artistic....cover for issue 23 has a naked piper and piper really didnt contribute much to the discoveries (that was paige and phoebe)
it also might have something to do with the aftermath! i wonder if they reverse renneks spell, the world will forget about magic and everything will go back to normal? -
#11
Definitely one of my favorites. I can't wait to see what happens, too bad we have to wait so long.
-
#12
For anyone who is interested, I just uploaded the rest of the page that cover was on. It's mostly an ad for the first three volumes along with the next two issues (24 and 25).
http://images.wikia.com/thecharmedcomics/images/4/4a/Charmed_Season_9_Ad.png -
#13
storygirl ur link isnt working
-
#14
@p4fan4ever - Sorry. I missed a piece.
http://images.wikia.com/thecharmedcomics/images/4/4a/Charmed_Season_9_Ad.png
Does that work now? -
#15
I'm going to try this one more time, but a little differently. Here it is: http://images.wikia.com/thecharmedcomics/
images/4/4a/Charmed_Season_9_Ad.png
Connect the two lines and you should be able to see it. If not, here's another link: http://thecharmedcomics.wikia.com/wiki/File:Charmed_Season_9_Ad.png -
#16
it works! and i see they got the volumes mixed up!
-
#17
This number would be classified by: Charmed 10x00 or 10x01???
-
#18
The sister do look ghostly, but I don't think the ruins are those of the manor. The columns look more like a Greek temple. I think there will be some more mythology. TCO becoming higher beings would be interesting, but then there are their families...
@p4fan4ever Good question. I think things will be back to normal. -
#19
They hold hands!!! This is real power of three out there! power of three sisters not only magic..
im glad paul brought that dimension back with prue -
#20
Looks like the manor in the background on the cover of issue 25 not a temple.
-
#21
it actually reminds me of a combination of the manor and Up There. both in ruins
-
#22
The steps look like the entrance to the manor, but I don't know about the columns.
Charmed #23 available today
Charmed #23 is out today.
If you read the issue today or want to be spoiled, write/read about it in the spoilers section here
-
#1
When will it get released on Comixology?
-
#2
later today i believe
-
#3
It's now available on Graphicly! :D
-
#4
@joshingabout could you write a synopsis in spoilers section???
-
#5
It is now available in Comixology too
-
#6
I've written a detailed summary in the spoilers section =]
-
#7
The issues storyline sounds great! And it does exactly what an issue before an arc's finale does. Set the ground for the big finale! 3 weeks left!
-
#8
I wanted to share something I found in my copy of Wonderland 2. And yes, it is labeled Charmed #25. I uploaded it and now those of you who don't read Wonderland can see it, too. Be aware it was a very small picture and rather grainy. My scanner blows everything up to larger sizes, so that's why it is the size it is.
http://images.wikia.com/thecharmedcomics/images/3/36/I25_-_Cover_AU.png -
#9
Oh my God!!! It's beautiful!!! Thank you very much, StoryGirl83!!!
Charmed #23 previews
Previews are from comicbookrealm.com
Enjoy
By the way, isn't this one of the best Piper likenesses?
-
#1
Yes, Piper is amazing!! I like Paige too!
-
#2
I absolutely love this artist!
-
#3
awesome
-
#4
I'm glad Paul warned us that "the oice from beyond the grave" wasn't going to be that huge, other wise I would've been disappointed that it turned out to just be Alexi...ahaha
-
#5
This issue looks great love the art and phoebe hair and likeness , cant wait for volume 4!
-
#6
Hopefully, there's still the exciting cameo.
-
#7
of course :) remember that the "exciting" cameo is only seen on a flashback and from behind so i'm sure that it's not the cameo Paul has in mind but only one of the 3 voices from beyond the grave
-
#8
and now that we know that the answer can be found on Leo's past life, the cameo will probably be linked to him. Maybe Leo's dad, Leo's past life during the 20s, adult chris or wyatt, gideon...
-
#9
I love this artist - he/she has really given the series its own look and I hope that Zenescope keep them for season 10. My one wish for season 10 is that we have a consistent creative team because season 9 has been a mess in that regard and having the artist/colourists change from issue to issue and then being stuck with Dean Kotz ruined my enjoyment of season 9 a lot.
-
#10
I'm glad Rubine is back!
-
#11
Wait, whose Alexi?
-
#12
@josephjaymes - Alexi was in two issues of the previous story arc. She was a former contact of Cole's whom he went to as a last resort. She was a seer and she worked with Rennek for a bit. As she said, she should have known not to trust him.
And honestly, I'm glad to see Alexi, again. I found her to be an interesting character. -
#13
I thought Paige's likeness was incredible, but I think she's the easiest to draw from the variations we've seen. I'm quite impressed with Piper too.
I liked that it looks like Prue is using Coop's arrows.
Is it just me or does Phoebe look a little chubby on the first page? -
#14
Chubby? Well, she just had a baby XD
-
#15
Personally I think she looks too young
-
#16
I agree. But before we can judge we have to see the whole issue, i think!
-
#17
Rubine in two issues has become the best artist to me (Besides Abreu, Tess and Maniquis), I really hope Zenescope keep him as the main artist in season 10 with Tess doing the one-shots!
-
#18
that would be the perfect plan! nick_clark :)
-
#19
It's the daisy duke pig tail thing she's got going on that makes her look young, imho. Piper and Paige have great likenesses and I still see Shannen in Prue's likeness, but that's just me I'm sure.
-
#20
i am so huppy because prue is in this issue
-
#21
i love prues Crossbows its really amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
-
#22
If release date for issue 24 is 26/9 . Then i really scare because it will be dean kortz work!!!
he will destroy the last issue -
#23
Where can I buy these in Australia?
-
#24
Comic Book stores. If they don't have them, order them. Or you can buy them digitally from comixology for example
-
#25
Am I the only one who enjoyed Kotz' artwork? He had improved infinitely from his debut in Issue 9. Rubine's work in Issue 22 wasn't my favourite by a long shot but judging from these previews he (she?) has improved greatly with the likenesses and overall looks, with Holly's likeness on par with Maniquis' =]
I really like that this issue, much like Tess' issues, has a graceful femininity to it, much like the show did. I think the colouring is very easy on the eye and compliments Rubine's lineart.
I absolutely cannot wait for tomorrow to get my hands on this issue. This arc/volume has been rather slow IMHO, so I hope that this issue picks things up a notch ready for the finale in a few weeks :D -
#26
Also, Alexi seems really old and frumpy in these previews. Perhaps that was the point since she's dead, but I really liked Kotz' vision of her where she was much more youthful.
I still want to know exactly what the Jewel of Orthonn is and if it'll play a part in this issue or the finale. -
#27
i beleieve that dean kortz destroyed season 9 vol 3 it was prues return but i dont enjoed because the sketches were awful
-
#28
Prue is really beautiful in this issue!!!!!!!!! Rubine is my favorite!!!!!!!!!!good work
-
#29
p2: I totally agree with you! Dean has improved but his drawings were incomplete and tiring! It would be really great if Zenescope chose Rubine as the artist for the whole season 10! I love his work! But how do you know that Dean will draw issue 24? It's a terrible news!
-
#30
I'm liking this new artist. Thank god Piper has long hair again. No offense to Dean, but she hadn't had it that short since season 1.
-
#31
@p3nathan - You mean except when Reno Maniquis drew her? Because he drew her hair pretty short.
-
#32
Wow! The first page is amazing, the others are dissapointing except for the liknesses... At least, dean's work had some constistency! Hate the colors and hate the artwork!
-
#33
@henry i am not so sure but only dean kortz finished a issue so soon
-
#34
@P2 - I'm not sure that has anything to do with it. We don't know how long the art work on this one has been done. Maybe there were hold ups with CBS and things needed to be redone. Or maybe there were issues with the colorist and it was taking too long. Who knows. I have a feeling Dean Kotz is not coming back. I could be wrong, but it seems likely with what has happened.
@JoshingAbout - My friend Es is very much with you about Dean Kotz. I think she will always love his art for drawing her pretty Ladybug. She's been very disappointed with how Phoebe's little girl has appeared in the comics. She's rather disappointed with Rubine and doesn't care for the likenesses. She has not seen these previews, so this is based entirely off of the previous issue.
Here's my opinion on artist likenesses of the characters or just what I think.
Prue - Tess (as Patience I think Rubine did win me over, but I still prefer little Prue's look)
Piper - Tess (issue 19)
Phoebe - Tess (issue 6)
Paige - Tess (issue 11), second place goes to Marcio for issue 7
Andy - Well, what do you think. Dean, but I do want something to compare it to.
Leo - Marcio (issue 7)
Coop - Dave (issue 1)
Cole - Reno (issue 10), second place goes to Rubine for issue 22
Henry - Tess (issue 19)
Wyatt - toss up between Tess (issue 11) and Reno (issue 13)
Chris - Tess (issue 11)
Melinda - Tess (issue 11), second place goes to Marciofor issue 5
P.J. - Dean (issue 14)
Parker - Dean, but there are no options
Kat and Tamora - Tess (issue 6 . . . Although I don't actually know which twin it is)
Henry, Jr - Tess (issue 19)
Grams - Tess (issue 11)
Patty - Dean (issue 12)
Victor - Tess, yes, there's only one choice, but I do love that likeness.
Sam - Tess (issue 11)
Elise - Tess (issue 6) I think although Dean in issue 20 was cool.
Kyle - Marcio (issue 7)
Neena - Carlos (issue 8)
Darryl - Rubine (issue 22)
Rennek - Marcio (issue 5)
Mika - Tess (issue 6)
Tyler - David Seidman (honestly I don't care for any of the interior versions of him, but if I had to chose it would be Dave for issue 3)
@Charmedforeveh - I am with you on the colors. I really want to get rid of this colorist. It's not the art that has been in my attention this arc, it's the colors. I'm sorry they don't have a different colorist, because I'm not a fan of Falk or Dash Martin. I miss Michael Spicer and I will be very glad for whatever issue John Hunt does. I would also love to see Jason Embury, again. Depending on who he's paired with, I'd also like Jorge Maese, again, too. -
#35
Jorge Maese has always been my favourite colourist. He made issues 10 and 12 so dark and atmospheric. I wasn't a fan of Michael Spicer in his first issues but combined with Tess' artwork it looked really great.
I don't mind this new colourist - I rather like the softer tone. It gives the series a nice feminine look IMHO, much like how in Seasons 5-8 the lighting changed from darker to lighter, making it seem more airy. I really disliked John Hunt's colouring in Issue 5 but in Issue 6 it worked. Sometimes they're just hit and miss. -
#36
Gah, I hate time zones ... it means I'll have to wait a few more hours before I can read the issue on Comixology or Graphicly. Le cry T_T
accacipi (Saturday, 06 October 2012 16:08)
Thank you for keeping us informed for more than two years! Can't wait for more news on season 10!!
crstal kincade (Wednesday, 10 October 2012 11:07)
iam a big huge fan of the show keep up the good job i look p to u guys
P2 (Thursday, 11 October 2012 10:05)
i love nathan review!!!!!!!!
Barron (Thursday, 11 October 2012 13:08)
The only question we need answered now: Was the flashforwards in Forever Charmed real or some sort of premonition?
Julie (Friday, 12 October 2012 14:52)
@ Barron I think it was a flash forward may have been real but I don't know.
charmedcomicfan (Saturday, 13 October 2012 16:40)
i believe they are real and so far Paul respects and follows the continuity of these flash forwards.
Barron (Sunday, 14 October 2012 21:06)
To me, they are premonitions witnessed by Phoebe. I rather them not be real so Cole and Phoebe can indeed get together.
p4fan4ever (Tuesday, 16 October 2012 04:38)
@henry I posted something for you in issue 24 spoilers about prue/patience and our theories!
TheFanatic (Thursday, 18 October 2012 16:33)
About your theories, I asked Paul on twitter if the issue would be addressed in the future and he said yes.
Julie (Friday, 19 October 2012 15:06)
Wish all of season 9 was just a dream.