@sephjames ohh sorry i didnt mean that phoebe is weak witch, of cource she is powerful because she is a charmed one! I mean that is too hard to find her sisters because is one but i think that she
can save the day. But i hope finally that prue helps her.
#46
sephjames(Tuesday, 14 June 2011 08:29)
@power of three: Phoebe is not weak. She is a Charmed One. All four of them are equally and individually strong. Phoebe may have somewhat weak powers, but she can still get the job done. I was
thinking Prue's return would make a little bit of sense in issue #11 or #12, but now I hope she doesn't return anytime soon because I hope Phoebe saves the day. I know Phoebe can do it anyway.
I suppose it is possible that Prue might return. I have had suspicions along those lines for months now, but I won't be holding my breath much as I want it to happen.
#44
power of three(Monday, 13 June 2011 17:41)
I hope that prue will make an appearence in issue 11-12 and somehow helps phoebe because she is weak to find alone paige and piper.i would love to see prue with piper to kill some demons together and
to she her with paige!
#43
Megawhatz123(Monday, 13 June 2011 13:14)
@fxrocks - Well she would fit the story cus the elders are hiding in the Ancestral Plane where Prue is so....
#42
fxrocks(Monday, 13 June 2011 05:17)
I don't think Prue will be part of volume 2, she wouldn't fit with the story but let's hope she's part of volume 3!!!
#41
JoshingAbout(Monday, 13 June 2011 04:14)
@p3nathan - I think that the images used on the special cover and in isuse #0 were images from Season 2, where Shannon didn't own her image, so they were allowed to be used. I hope that Ruditis could
convince Shannen for her image to be used, since the comics have no relation to Brad Kern or the WB she may be lenient - who knows? I really hope she does for the fans.
I wouldn't mind Prue coming back tbh - she'd kick ass in the comics.
#40
p3nathan(Sunday, 12 June 2011 12:34)
Wasn't Shannen's image used on a special cover already... so surely any permission has already been asked for? I personally won't believe it until I see proof.
#39
sarah(Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:28)
if prue came they would not
be the power or three
#38
charmedcomicfan(Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:16)
and lets say this is true. how come you know that?
#37
charmedcomicfan(Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:14)
@edgeofglory Dont say that like you know what is going to happen for sure....
#36
TheEdgeOfGlory(Saturday, 11 June 2011 11:09)
Prue returns in the final issue of volume 2! That is why Zenescope was delaying issues! They needed Shannen Doherty's permission to use her image and she agree a couple weeks ago!!!
@JoshingAbout - That is an interesting theory that might be worth investigating.
#34
JoshingAbout(Friday, 10 June 2011 19:00)
I too picked up on this. It might have something to do with her Empathy power being forcably stripped from her by the Tribunal. This may have negated the effects of the Empathy-blocking potion as
Phoebe no longer had the power. So, when she earned the power back in "Innocents Lost", the potion may longer be in effect, and Phoebe can now use her Empathy to detect Piper and Paige's emotions?
#33
chloefan03(Friday, 10 June 2011 14:51)
i was thinking just like you, but maybe the question should be asked to Paul to see if he made a mistake or if that was intentional? maybe you could ask on twitter?:)
@Chloefan03 - That bothered me to, but a friend told me that she thought that was just temporary and that later on Phoebe showed signs of being able to control her power more, so its possible that
Phoebe can get around blocking potions or else the blocking potion wore off and Phoebe can call for feeling emotions at will.
Anyone else have thoughts on that?
#31
chloefan03(Friday, 10 June 2011 07:44)
i have a question: Phoebe says she can't feel any emotion from Paige but it's normal since in Love's a witch (6x05) her and Piper drunk a potion for Phoebe not being bothered by their emotions, no?
#30
sarah(Friday, 10 June 2011 07:14)
charmed is the best if you could have any power from the show what would it be mine is preminiton
#29
sarah(Thursday, 09 June 2011 16:58)
hmmm thx never thought about that but opiper was dead i though when he healed her
@Sarah - I'm guessing that Paige (and Kyle, I guess) are either in the place where Leo healed Piper in "Awakened" or in the place with Chris was concieved in "The Courtship of Wyatt's Father".
#27
sarah(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 19:07)
thx
#26
JoshingAbout(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 18:25)
This issue makes me love Neena all the more - I consider her to be the cleverest villian in Charmed history. I don't even care if she's the most overpowered thing ever, she's amazing.
I wonder why the powers of the Underworld and the Heavens were behind the grand doors? It makes little sense that evil magic would reside "Up There", and how it'd get up there in the first
place.
My theory is that the two orbs, one red and one blue, signify the spirits of Neena's two children: one good and one evil, as she refers to them as "my sweetlings", and the Elders kept the two spirits
up there so Evil wouldn't try to harness the Warlock's powers.
I think she's going to use the power of her progeny to try and merge the Heavens and the Underworld with the Higher Realm, if that's at all possible, although it might be, since Neena is tied to The
All and her children are possibly the most powerful magic users next to her.
#25
Courtney(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 17:37)
So, I'm guessing Neena gave the apple to Cole so he can give it to Piper since he was surprised.
Does it specifically say that the red and blue balls represent The Upper Regions and The Underworld? or just good and evil?
me too :p and from greece. I know your name is sarah sorry i mispelled. As for Paige she is in the ghostly plane that means she is close to death, but not dead yet
#23
sarah(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:30)
pss also im not over 19 lol im like 18
#22
sarah(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:26)
ps its sarah
#21
sarah(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:26)
im sorry im not the best at typeing thw thing i dopnt get is shes alive but in thje ghost plane ah never mind
Srah its Paige not Pagie and twins not twines, you do these mistakes all the time thats why i correct you. Paige is badly hurt. i think she is in the ghostly plane, as for the rest of the comment i
dont understand what you try to say.
#19
the power of three(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:18)
piper is the new lady of lake and wyatt the true master.in sword and the city we see that paige call for the excalibur but failed the excalibur cant handled by them. i think only these people can
wield it.even piper can't completely wield too much.thats why she dont use it a lot.
#18
sarah(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:07)
ok first why is pagie in a limbo with kyle :o AND neena better not hurt henry or the twines lol see henry should be a whitelighter and the twines need powers too lol
I think anyone can hold the excalibur after its removed from the chosen on from the stone. But they cant wield it too much because the sword changes the wielder who is not chosen (see piper in sword
and the city)
#16
the power of three(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 15:55)
im sure that paige will revenge neena in offensive charmed for threatening her family!in issue 12 paige hold a sword i hope that is not excalibur(because only piper and wyatt can hold it) and i hope
to be a another legendary sword or something else like the glowing balls!i think that charmed ones will use these things(sword,blue and red ball) to defeat neena!kat and tamora made an appearence in
this issue?
@Tess - Reno definitely did do an excellent job. So far in this story arc, I think issue #10 is THE best issue in the arc both in storyline and in art work. I can't wait to see the next issue with
your art work and see how the issue runs through. With the way this issue was left it should be quite interesting.
On a different note: It was nice to see that Phoebe's hair is now down. I like it better that way.
There was quite an interesting cast in this issue with the three girls, all three husbands, two exs, and Paige's three kids (plus of course Neena, Rennek, and their group).
#14
charmedcomicfan(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:42)
ALL categories are now updated!
#13
charmedcomicfan(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:20)
sHe threatened Henry, her kids and Leo, cause at the moment those are the people she can hurt
#12
Charmedfan2011(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:14)
When u say neena threathened paiges family do u mean Henry, Tamora, Kat, Henry or Piper pheobe leo????
and also cole wears a different suit than the suit he wears in the end of issue 9, and in a parallel wasteland-plane im not so sure how accesible a new suit is :P
Reno's the best by far. And I'm including me in that. I adore what he's done. The one thing that bothered me was Cole's suit with the 70's style disco collar. And yes, also Henry's hair. But I think
Reno is just wonderful. My favorite!! So glad you enjoyed the issue.
Cole knows neena but a relation with her hasnt been revealed yet. as for likeness: Cole and Piper are uncanny, perfect likeness.Coop and Phoebe were my least favorite but still good. Paige had some
panels that looks exactly like rose mcgowan. Henry had a great face likeness but i didnt understand his hair, they were kinda off
#8
chloefan03(Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:43)
Cole's attitude seems very strange...he's surely related to Neena but how? i'm dying to know what happens next! Paul is really a great writer:)
Leo and Paige are Up There glamoured as demons trying to find Piper. Neena sees through their glamour and reverses it revealing Paige and Leo to the demons.
Phoebe and Coop are in the attic, Phoebe stayed behind in case anything went wrong.
Piper and Cole discuss the events of The Seven Year Witch when they last met. Piper tells him that she is suspicious of him. Cole offers the apple to Piper but she refuses to take it. Piper asks if
this is a ploy for Cole to get Phoebe back and she explains that she's married and has a kid. Cole says that he's only there to help. Piper asks if he is working with Neena, Cole answers vaguely and
tells Piper that he is her only chance of escaping.
Up There Neena forces Paige to open the gates by threatening her family.
Back at the manor Phoebe decides to try and find Neena's lover in an effort to find her.
Up There Paige opens the gates which reveals a room containing two glowing balls, one red and one blue. Paige runs while Leo fends off a demon, Rennek captures Leo and Leo tells Paige to escape. She
promises she'll be back but Paige is attacked by a demon mid orb at the same time Neena tries to send her through a portal.
Piper asks for the apple after a portal opens and closes before she can get to it.
Phoebe chants a spell to find her ancestor which ends up causing a mess in the attic. She gives up and Paige orbs in unconscious and barely breathing. Phoebe can't sense any emptions from her. Henry
runs into the attic and carries her into Piper's room and Phoebe promises to figure out what to do to save her.
Piper takes a bite from the apple and collapses. Cole stands over her body surprised as she wasn't meant to collapse.
Paige is in limbo with Kyle who has yet to move on.
The final page sees Neena with the two balls, she wants to be reunited with her beloved after she brings together the underworld and the heavens and the sisters separated.
power of three (Wednesday, 15 June 2011)
@sephjames ohh sorry i didnt mean that phoebe is weak witch, of cource she is powerful because she is a charmed one! I mean that is too hard to find her sisters because is one but i think that she can save the day. But i hope finally that prue helps her.
sephjames (Tuesday, 14 June 2011 08:29)
@power of three: Phoebe is not weak. She is a Charmed One. All four of them are equally and individually strong. Phoebe may have somewhat weak powers, but she can still get the job done. I was thinking Prue's return would make a little bit of sense in issue #11 or #12, but now I hope she doesn't return anytime soon because I hope Phoebe saves the day. I know Phoebe can do it anyway.
StoryGirl83 (Tuesday, 14 June 2011 01:40)
I suppose it is possible that Prue might return. I have had suspicions along those lines for months now, but I won't be holding my breath much as I want it to happen.
power of three (Monday, 13 June 2011 17:41)
I hope that prue will make an appearence in issue 11-12 and somehow helps phoebe because she is weak to find alone paige and piper.i would love to see prue with piper to kill some demons together and to she her with paige!
Megawhatz123 (Monday, 13 June 2011 13:14)
@fxrocks - Well she would fit the story cus the elders are hiding in the Ancestral Plane where Prue is so....
fxrocks (Monday, 13 June 2011 05:17)
I don't think Prue will be part of volume 2, she wouldn't fit with the story but let's hope she's part of volume 3!!!
JoshingAbout (Monday, 13 June 2011 04:14)
@p3nathan - I think that the images used on the special cover and in isuse #0 were images from Season 2, where Shannon didn't own her image, so they were allowed to be used. I hope that Ruditis could convince Shannen for her image to be used, since the comics have no relation to Brad Kern or the WB she may be lenient - who knows? I really hope she does for the fans.
I wouldn't mind Prue coming back tbh - she'd kick ass in the comics.
p3nathan (Sunday, 12 June 2011 12:34)
Wasn't Shannen's image used on a special cover already... so surely any permission has already been asked for? I personally won't believe it until I see proof.
sarah (Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:28)
if prue came they would not
be the power or three
charmedcomicfan (Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:16)
and lets say this is true. how come you know that?
charmedcomicfan (Saturday, 11 June 2011 12:14)
@edgeofglory Dont say that like you know what is going to happen for sure....
TheEdgeOfGlory (Saturday, 11 June 2011 11:09)
Prue returns in the final issue of volume 2! That is why Zenescope was delaying issues! They needed Shannen Doherty's permission to use her image and she agree a couple weeks ago!!!
StoryGirl83 (Friday, 10 June 2011 21:58)
@JoshingAbout - That is an interesting theory that might be worth investigating.
JoshingAbout (Friday, 10 June 2011 19:00)
I too picked up on this. It might have something to do with her Empathy power being forcably stripped from her by the Tribunal. This may have negated the effects of the Empathy-blocking potion as Phoebe no longer had the power. So, when she earned the power back in "Innocents Lost", the potion may longer be in effect, and Phoebe can now use her Empathy to detect Piper and Paige's emotions?
chloefan03 (Friday, 10 June 2011 14:51)
i was thinking just like you, but maybe the question should be asked to Paul to see if he made a mistake or if that was intentional? maybe you could ask on twitter?:)
StoryGirl83 (Friday, 10 June 2011 14:21)
@Chloefan03 - That bothered me to, but a friend told me that she thought that was just temporary and that later on Phoebe showed signs of being able to control her power more, so its possible that Phoebe can get around blocking potions or else the blocking potion wore off and Phoebe can call for feeling emotions at will.
Anyone else have thoughts on that?
chloefan03 (Friday, 10 June 2011 07:44)
i have a question: Phoebe says she can't feel any emotion from Paige but it's normal since in Love's a witch (6x05) her and Piper drunk a potion for Phoebe not being bothered by their emotions, no?
sarah (Friday, 10 June 2011 07:14)
charmed is the best if you could have any power from the show what would it be mine is preminiton
sarah (Thursday, 09 June 2011 16:58)
hmmm thx never thought about that but opiper was dead i though when he healed her
StoryGirl83 (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 23:04)
@Sarah - I'm guessing that Paige (and Kyle, I guess) are either in the place where Leo healed Piper in "Awakened" or in the place with Chris was concieved in "The Courtship of Wyatt's Father".
sarah (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 19:07)
thx
JoshingAbout (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 18:25)
This issue makes me love Neena all the more - I consider her to be the cleverest villian in Charmed history. I don't even care if she's the most overpowered thing ever, she's amazing.
I wonder why the powers of the Underworld and the Heavens were behind the grand doors? It makes little sense that evil magic would reside "Up There", and how it'd get up there in the first place.
My theory is that the two orbs, one red and one blue, signify the spirits of Neena's two children: one good and one evil, as she refers to them as "my sweetlings", and the Elders kept the two spirits up there so Evil wouldn't try to harness the Warlock's powers.
I think she's going to use the power of her progeny to try and merge the Heavens and the Underworld with the Higher Realm, if that's at all possible, although it might be, since Neena is tied to The All and her children are possibly the most powerful magic users next to her.
Courtney (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 17:37)
So, I'm guessing Neena gave the apple to Cole so he can give it to Piper since he was surprised.
Does it specifically say that the red and blue balls represent The Upper Regions and The Underworld? or just good and evil?
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:34)
me too :p and from greece. I know your name is sarah sorry i mispelled. As for Paige she is in the ghostly plane that means she is close to death, but not dead yet
sarah (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:30)
pss also im not over 19 lol im like 18
sarah (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:26)
ps its sarah
sarah (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:26)
im sorry im not the best at typeing thw thing i dopnt get is shes alive but in thje ghost plane ah never mind
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:19)
Srah its Paige not Pagie and twins not twines, you do these mistakes all the time thats why i correct you. Paige is badly hurt. i think she is in the ghostly plane, as for the rest of the comment i dont understand what you try to say.
the power of three (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:18)
piper is the new lady of lake and wyatt the true master.in sword and the city we see that paige call for the excalibur but failed the excalibur cant handled by them. i think only these people can wield it.even piper can't completely wield too much.thats why she dont use it a lot.
sarah (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 16:07)
ok first why is pagie in a limbo with kyle :o AND neena better not hurt henry or the twines lol see henry should be a whitelighter and the twines need powers too lol
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 15:58)
I think anyone can hold the excalibur after its removed from the chosen on from the stone. But they cant wield it too much because the sword changes the wielder who is not chosen (see piper in sword and the city)
the power of three (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 15:55)
im sure that paige will revenge neena in offensive charmed for threatening her family!in issue 12 paige hold a sword i hope that is not excalibur(because only piper and wyatt can hold it) and i hope to be a another legendary sword or something else like the glowing balls!i think that charmed ones will use these things(sword,blue and red ball) to defeat neena!kat and tamora made an appearence in this issue?
StoryGirl83 (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 14:50)
@Tess - Reno definitely did do an excellent job. So far in this story arc, I think issue #10 is THE best issue in the arc both in storyline and in art work. I can't wait to see the next issue with your art work and see how the issue runs through. With the way this issue was left it should be quite interesting.
On a different note: It was nice to see that Phoebe's hair is now down. I like it better that way.
There was quite an interesting cast in this issue with the three girls, all three husbands, two exs, and Paige's three kids (plus of course Neena, Rennek, and their group).
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:42)
ALL categories are now updated!
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:20)
sHe threatened Henry, her kids and Leo, cause at the moment those are the people she can hurt
Charmedfan2011 (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 12:14)
When u say neena threathened paiges family do u mean Henry, Tamora, Kat, Henry or Piper pheobe leo????
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 10:31)
and also cole wears a different suit than the suit he wears in the end of issue 9, and in a parallel wasteland-plane im not so sure how accesible a new suit is :P
Tess (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 10:25)
Reno's the best by far. And I'm including me in that. I adore what he's done. The one thing that bothered me was Cole's suit with the 70's style disco collar. And yes, also Henry's hair. But I think Reno is just wonderful. My favorite!! So glad you enjoyed the issue.
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:54)
Cole knows neena but a relation with her hasnt been revealed yet. as for likeness: Cole and Piper are uncanny, perfect likeness.Coop and Phoebe were my least favorite but still good. Paige had some panels that looks exactly like rose mcgowan. Henry had a great face likeness but i didnt understand his hair, they were kinda off
chloefan03 (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:43)
Cole's attitude seems very strange...he's surely related to Neena but how? i'm dying to know what happens next! Paul is really a great writer:)
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:10)
they SURE are. the red represents underworld and evil yes and the blue represents heaven "up there" and good
the power of three (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:08)
im sure that these balls are the balls that phoebe and piper hold in issue offensive charmed!propably the red ball is the evil and blue the good!
charmedcomicfan (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:05)
orbing, orb shield, pyrogenism and portal creation
the power of three (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 06:02)
thank you! what powers are used?
chloefan03 (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 05:59)
wow, i ,think i'm gonna love this issue! i'm really happy to know that Jyle is still here:)
David (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 05:50)
Here's a quick summary of the issue:
Leo and Paige are Up There glamoured as demons trying to find Piper. Neena sees through their glamour and reverses it revealing Paige and Leo to the demons.
Phoebe and Coop are in the attic, Phoebe stayed behind in case anything went wrong.
Piper and Cole discuss the events of The Seven Year Witch when they last met. Piper tells him that she is suspicious of him. Cole offers the apple to Piper but she refuses to take it. Piper asks if this is a ploy for Cole to get Phoebe back and she explains that she's married and has a kid. Cole says that he's only there to help. Piper asks if he is working with Neena, Cole answers vaguely and tells Piper that he is her only chance of escaping.
Up There Neena forces Paige to open the gates by threatening her family.
Back at the manor Phoebe decides to try and find Neena's lover in an effort to find her.
Up There Paige opens the gates which reveals a room containing two glowing balls, one red and one blue. Paige runs while Leo fends off a demon, Rennek captures Leo and Leo tells Paige to escape. She promises she'll be back but Paige is attacked by a demon mid orb at the same time Neena tries to send her through a portal.
Piper asks for the apple after a portal opens and closes before she can get to it.
Phoebe chants a spell to find her ancestor which ends up causing a mess in the attic. She gives up and Paige orbs in unconscious and barely breathing. Phoebe can't sense any emptions from her. Henry runs into the attic and carries her into Piper's room and Phoebe promises to figure out what to do to save her.
Piper takes a bite from the apple and collapses. Cole stands over her body surprised as she wasn't meant to collapse.
Paige is in limbo with Kyle who has yet to move on.
The final page sees Neena with the two balls, she wants to be reunited with her beloved after she brings together the underworld and the heavens and the sisters separated.
the power of three (Wednesday, 08 June 2011 04:04)
what happens??? and what powers are used?